Resilient Bees Survive Notre Dame’s Catastrophic Fire

Beekeeper Nicolas Geant kept three hives on the roof of the Cathedral of Notre Dame.

Unknown to even many Parisians, three hives of bees were living on the roof of Notre Dame. Even more surprising, despite the inferno that caused such devastating damage to the famous Cathedral, the bees remain alive and well, having survived the inferno that burned Notre Dame in March 2019.

The beekeeper confirmed (as reported on CNN):
“I got a call from Andre Finot, the spokesman for Notre Dame, who said there were bees flying in and out of the hives which means they are still alive! Right after the fire I looked at the drone pictures and saw the hives weren’t burnt but there was no way of knowing if the bees had survived. Now I know there’s activity it’s a huge relief!”

Notre Dame has housed three beehives on the roof over the sacristy, just beneath the rose window, since 2013. Each hive has about 60,000 bees. The beekeeper said the hives were not touched by the blaze because they are located about 100 feet below the main roof where the fire spread.

Location of beehives on roof of Cathedral of Notre Dame in Paris
Location of 3 Beehives on Roof of Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris

While it is likely that the hives filled with smoke during the fire, as we beekeepers know, that doesn’t affect the bees as it does us humans because bees don’t have lungs. We regularly smoke our bees when we open our hives to inspect them and that merely calms the bees down, and may interrupt their communication with one another or affect their choice to keep honey in their bodies momentarily. But the smoke does not harm them provided there is no fire and not too much heat.

If the temperature had gotten hot enough to melt the wax combs inside the hive, the bees would have become stuck together and would have all perished. However, because heat rises, and the hives were below the actual fire, the bees survived.

As the Notre Dame beekeeper said, “They weren’t in the middle of the fire, had they been they wouldn’t have survived. The hives are made of wood so they would have gone up in flames. “

“Bees don’t have lungs like us. And secondly, for centuries to work with the bees we have used bee smokers. A bee smoker is a box with bellows which creates a white, thick cold smoke in the hives, prompting the bees to calmly gorge on the honey while beekeepers do their work”

Notre Dame Bees on Gargoyle of Notre Dame, Miraculously Alive After the Inferno

Using Beneficial Insects for Hive Health

Recently, and very sadly, one of our hives absconded, we think due to hive beetles. Absconding means the whole hive leaves. Swarming usually involves smaller numbers of bees, with one queen, departing, leaving some remaining bees behind, perhaps with a second queen, or about to make a new queen.

The only good news about a hive absconding is that you know the hive flew off. There are few or no dead bees left behind, or outside the hive, as you’d discover if a hive was poisoned by pesticides, or succumbed to Varroa mites, or attack from another hive.

Absconding usually means the bees were finding it hard to live in the hive for some reason. The important thing is to figure out what the reason was. I had been down at the hives and noticed almost no bees going in and out of hive 3. Just the week or two before it had been thriving. I did find one dead bee right at the entrance. The hive felt cold to the outside touch and there was no lovely humming sound coming from the hive. Nervously, I opened the hive – and discovered it empty of bees. I noticed something I’d never seen in one of my hives before – a black beetle walking on the inside of the hive. Upon closer inspection, there were a good number of these beetles on the lower part of the hive where the brood were. As we pulled out the frames, one by one, we were shocked to see all the honey gone. Well, at least that might mean that the honeybees gorged and filled themselves up with their honey to take it with them.

beetle larva
a beetle, dead bee and larva
black hive beetle



We also noticed not much brood and some capped brood prematurely uncapped. Upon reading, we learned that hive beetles feed on honeybee larva and honey. If the number of beetles gets too large, it weakens the hive by making the bees work harder than ever and not gain any ground as their honey and next generation of offspring get eaten by the beetles.

To kill the bees in the hives, we installed super easy to use and effective bee blaster strips on top of the hive between frames. We filled with vegetable oil (to drown the beetles).

We also put a neat little trap on the bottom of the hive to kill any down there (the beetles go to these two places often so you can kill them when they’re there). They are thin black plastic containers. You open them up, put a little honey and boric acid in the middle. The honey attracts the beetle and the boric acid kills them. Only the beetles can get in the holes, which are too small for the bees. You check the traps periodically and discard the dead beetles.

To be sure the hive beetles didn’t return to the area where we keep our hives, or live underneath the hives, it’s recommended to put a layer of gravel or rocks on the ground under the hive. We also distributed two types of beneficial nematodes under and around the hive and in all the greenery nearby.

This beneficial nematode, called Steinernema riobrave, is specifically good at eating hive beetles like the ones we had in our hive. We wish we’d been using the nematodes earlier before we lost our hive!

From the arbico-organics website: Steinernema riobrave are naturally occurring, soil dwelling ambush predators that control a wide range of turf and citrus pests including armyworms, black cutworms, citrus weevils and Japanese Beetle grubs. They are also significantly more effective for treatment of subterranean termites than some of their counterparts. Similar to other nematode species, S. riobrave release a bacteria once they have infected the pest. This bacteria slows feeding and kills the pest within 24-48 hours of infection. The beneficial nematodes will continue to reproduce inside their host after death and emerge ready to infect other hosts. Best yet, you can release these nematodes around your vegetables, fruit trees, and other consumable crops, and near your pets or livestock…even indoors. They are safe.

Here’s the link to where we bought our supply. We actually used NemaSeek and NemaAttack https://www.arbico-organics.com/product/beneficial-nematodes-steinernema-riobrave This is what the contents look like. It’s pretty easy to use. All you need to add is water. You need a strainer to remove the gel after you add water and agitate to activate the nematodes before you distribute them. If you have a sprayer, that’s the best way to apply them.

Another good year of Golden Glow Honey Production

DSC02964_1024

that reddish-brown longer-bodied bee in the center is one of our queens

DSC05067_1024

Ellen gets ready to scrape the wax off with a hot knife so she can harvest the honey from the comb on the frame


Enjoy our video showing how to harvest honey from our beehive frames!
DSC03603_1024 DSC04100_1024 DSC02958_1024 DSC02967_1024

Honey Helper

We enlist the expert help of Hilary Kearney to watch our hives and harvest our honey as we aren’t in Southern California very often. She is wonderful, super knowledgeable, and can be a great resource for anyone needing help with bees in San Diego area or just with information in general. She runs classes, writes an excellent blog, and has a good instagram account. Check out Girl Next Door Honey!

Summer Solstice Beehive Check

We checked our two hives on June 21st and found they were both doing very well. Interestingly, our left hive has surpassed the right one in status even though we established this hive about 3 weeks after the right hive. There are more capped honey frames filled in the left hive than the right. We also notice more bees in the top honey super on the left than the right. Also, the bees in the left hive drink their sugar-water supplementation about three times as fast as the bees in the right hive

DSC04595_1024

showing the golden honey in the sun

DSC04590_1024

note the small section of capped honey on top

We’re not sure if it’s the reason why the left hive is more robust and is growing faster, but the bees in the left hive are also much more aggressive than the bees on the right. Could they have a touch of Africanism, we wonder?

DSC04606_1024

left hive: large capped area

DSC04591

right hive – less honey capped so far

More photos of the honey build up in the top supers of our hives:   DSC04598_1024  DSC04600_1024 DSC04587_1024DSC04591_1024DSC04590_1024 DSC04592_1024

Memorial Day Honey

Last year, we had not even rescued our first hives of bees by Memorial Day. This year, we added two new hives and got them early in the season (February in California).  We’ve also been feeding both hives steadily with 1:1 sugar:water syrup, and prior to when we added the honey supers, we also fed the hives Pro-Bee cakes.  Our hope is that these two factors will allow us to take one small draw of honey prior to the fall.

Today, we decided to reward ourselves with a first taste of honey. Our bees have been busily filling the honey supers (two medium on each hive) with honey. It’s still too early to do a full honey draw because the honey isn’t full in either super, nor is it capped.  But in inspecting the hives today, hive 1 had several pieces of comb that the bees had built up between frames. For hive maintenance – and conveniently to collect some honey – we removed the extra comb.

I had brought a large metal bowl down to the honey grove just in case such a situation presented itself.IMG_7857_1024 Of course many bees came with the comb into the bowl, but we gently and patiently brushed them off the comb, and back into the hive, leaving us with beautiful comb dripping with honey. Rand showed me that I could chew on the comb, much like chewing gum. What a pleasure! Our honey is indescribably sweet and flavorful. I can’t wait to do a proper draw and share it with our friends and family!

IMG_7854_1024DSC04115_1024

bees on the honey super’s frames:

DSC04112_1024DSC04112_1024 DSC04110_1024

End of March check-in

Both beehives are humming and as Spring is coming into full bloom, they have lots to eat from the garden. On the theory that a well-fed bee is a healthy, happy bee, we’ve been supplementing with 10/1 sugar patties, and 1/1 sugar-water syrup still. And they are still consuming about one large ball jar a day!

Here is hive #1: DSC03599_1024

And here’s a video showing their activity around the entrance, and how many are returning with pollen-filled legs. http://youtu.be/IVBfGIYX6_Y

Tomorrow, we’ll check inside the hives